tahir ul qadri ne apne lectures me INCIDENT OF DOOR ko jhota proof karna
caha he....or bazahir bari kaamyabi se us ne esa kia bhi he!
Qadri ne apni speech me KITAB SULAYM BIN QAIS HILALI ko jhoota(fabricated) kaha he.....or is kitab ko jis me ye incident of door sab se pehle likha gya he ko fake book proof karna caha he....or apni support me acche khase points kahe hen jo koch ye hen!
1-First recording in Shia book by - Sulaym bin Qais al Amari bin Hilali: "Al-Saqifa"
--he was sitting in the house of Abdullah ibn Abbas with some shia of Ali companions, when he got informed of umar burning the house.
book me se read ki magar mujhe kahin bhi ye sentence ""Abdullah ibn Abbas with some shia of Ali companions""" nazar nahi aya..bal k ye pori tradition sulaym bin qais HAZRAT SALMAN FARSI(R.A) se narrate karte hen!
Qadri ne apni speech me KITAB SULAYM BIN QAIS HILALI ko jhoota(fabricated) kaha he.....or is kitab ko jis me ye incident of door sab se pehle likha gya he ko fake book proof karna caha he....or apni support me acche khase points kahe hen jo koch ye hen!
1-First recording in Shia book by - Sulaym bin Qais al Amari bin Hilali: "Al-Saqifa"
--he was sitting in the house of Abdullah ibn Abbas with some shia of Ali companions, when he got informed of umar burning the house.
book me se read ki magar mujhe kahin bhi ye sentence ""Abdullah ibn Abbas with some shia of Ali companions""" nazar nahi aya..bal k ye pori tradition sulaym bin qais HAZRAT SALMAN FARSI(R.A) se narrate karte hen!
2-The book is a lie itself. Big shia ulema have rejected the book's authencity, because it was the first book to bring hadiths of the Qur'an being changed. That was the first topic Sulaym mentioned in his book.
ye jo claim kia he k "it was the first book to bring hadiths of the Qur'an being changed" ye mujhe is pori book me kahin nahi mila.( bal k ye likha ye he k IMAM ALI(A.S) ne kaha k jo alfaaaz hazrat usmaan k jama karda quran me hen wahi alfaaaz mere jama karda quran me hen...or agar tum hazrat usmaan k jama karda quran (jo k pora he) par amal karo ge to jannat me jao ge(me ne ye roughly yahan quote kia he)
3-Allamah Hilli, in Rijal e Hilli (one fo Asma ur Rijal -Big shia books), in pg 206 states that Abaan bin Ayyash has written this book, but since all is the sayings of Sulaym it is mentioned as the book of Sulaym, but this is book is baatil and lies since this Abaan is considered weak, and ascribed all to Sulaym?
ye claim k Abaan bin Ayyash ne ye book likhi...ye to sara sar ghalat he! me ne book me parha he k jab sulaym ko apni moat ka khatra howa(kio k un dino hajjaj IMAM ALI k ashab ko shaheed kar raha tha) to unho ne ye book abban bin ayyash ko dedi(in written form)!
ab jab ye book khod sulaym bin qais ne likhi he to abban bin ayyash ko ZAIEF kehne se kia faida(if abban was zaief)?
No comments:
Post a Comment